Programming by Equivalence

I would like to introduce a programming technique called “Programming by Equivalence”. You can't use it all the time, but when you can use it, it’s great.

Problem: You have an existing feature X, and you want to implement a similar feature Y.

Solution: For every line of code for X, create a line of code for Y.

The beauty of this technique is:

  1. You don't need to think much - just find each line of code for X and make an equivalent line of code for Y.
  2. You know when you are done: when every line of code for X has an equivalent line of code for Y.

Here is a script that can help you to do 1 and 2 above. Just tweak the variables in the script to match your own code. Suppose you have implemented Google +1 buttons in your codebase, and now you want to add LinkedIn buttons. Run the script, and you will get output like:

lib/XG_ConfigHelper.php::: return B()->getMainConfig('googlePlusOneEnabled') === '1';
lib/components/bundle/controllers/EntryController.php::: if (R('XG_ConfigHelper')->isGooglePlusOneEnabled()) {
lib/components/bundle/lib/EntryListService.php::: if (R('XG_ConfigHelper')->isGooglePlusOneEnabled()) {
lib/components/bundle/lib/MustacheTransformer.php::: ->socialButtons()->googlePlusOneButton($entry);
lib/mustache-templates/v1/bundle/article/list.mustache::: {{{googlePlusOneButtonHtml}}}
. . . . . . . . . .

Note that the script looks for the X string (in my case, googlePlusOne) and checks if a corresponding Y string exists. The script outputs any X lines that do not have corresponding Y lines.

Using this technique, the creation of feature Y becomes mechanical. You keep running the script, and keep implementing the lines that it finds. If there are any lines that are false-positives, you mark those lines in the script. When the script's output is empty, you're done.

Thus you can be quite confident that you have thoroughly implemented the new feature.

comments powered by Disqus

Did you know?

I'm a software engineering consultant. This means I can help your company with your software engineering needs:

  • providing temporary manpower for short-staffed software projects

  • helping new software projects get off to a good architectural start

  • improving the performance and reliability of old, legacy software systems

  • doing an important investigation or small project that you've always wanted to do but haven't had time for

Since 1999, I have done software engineering projects for the Canadian government, for Silicon Valley startups, and for established Bay Area companies, for small companies and medium-sized companies, for successful commercial projects and open-source projects. 

Currently accepting small projects. If you have one, email or call me.